The McGehee Zone
Login     Blogroll
Atop Clingmans Dome, November 2007

<< Previous Entry
Marketing
  Next Entry >>
A Ray of Good News



The Great Georgia-Tennessee Border War Over Water

Sat   9 Feb 2008   8:00

by Kevin McGehee
31° and sunny
in Coweta County, GA

2 comments

[Our Times]
[Wackadoodle]

If you haven’t already heard about this, the current drought conditions in most of Georgia have caused some of our lawmakers to rediscover an old surveying error that resulted in Georgia’s northern boundary being about a mile south of where it should have been.

Seems if the surveyors had done their job right, the Tennessee River would have just kissed the northwest corner of Georgia, thus offering the Peach State access to its water.

Tennesseeans reacted with humor, anger and defiance Thursday to Georgia’s legislative attempt to move the border north so the drought-plagued state can tap into the Tennessee River. “Us good Tennesseeans will take our long rifles up to Lookout Mountain and fire when ready,“ said Justin Wilson, a Nashville attorney and former deputy governor. Sen. David Shafer (R-Duluth) and Rep. Harry Geisinger (R-Roswell) introduced resolutions this week to, in essence, move the state line a mile north which would run the border right through a bend in the river. Then, the legislators say, Georgia could send billions of gallons of water to parched Atlanta without Tennessee’s permission. Shafer, Geisinger and others say an “erroneous” survey completed in 1818 placed the border 1.1 miles below what Congress had earlier established as the boundary. Virtually every Georgia legislator signed on to the resolutions (SR 822 and HR 1206), which direct Gov. Sonny Perdue to remedy the border dispute with his Tennessee counterpart.

» Water war between the states is for real

We’re already at war with Alabama and Florida over water, so why not also Tennessee?

Of course, shifting the border wouldn’t only affect that one corner of Georgia…

The mayor of McCaysville, Ga., Buddy Finch, 78, said it’s hard to say what the long-term repercussions will be if the border dispute between Georgia and Tennessee becomes more than just a political dust up over water. The Tennessee-Georgia state line cuts through the heart of McCaysville, separating it from Copper Hill, Tenn. If the line moves about a mile north—where some Georgians argue it belongs—Copper Hill will be swallowed by McCaysville. [...] Vest and Finch said they hadn’t heard about the latest fracas, but it didn’t surprise them. “People have been talking about the border up here for years,“ said Finch. Robert K. Ballew, a Blue Ridge, Ga., lawyer who was born 82 years ago in Copper Hill “50 feet inside the Tennessee line,“ said he was not sure what the legal ramifications might be if the line moves, but he might end up Tennessean by birth, but Georgian by Supreme Court decision. “Locally it’s always been known to be wrong and in error; that’s not in dispute,“ he said. “But there’s never been a concerted effort to change that.“

» Georgia town at the heart of border dispute

My mother-in-law in Chattanooga lives within a mile of the Georgia line. If this silliness were actually to happen, she would end up living in Georgia without having lifted a finger.

This would also affect Georgia’s border with North Carolina, and probably Tennessee’s borders with Alabama and Mississippi and North Carolina’s border with South Carolina. So I think what’s most likely to happen is the courts will simply direct Georgia and Tennessee to make nice and negotiate on Tennessee River water for Georgia.

 

CGHill said:

Don’t expect this to clear up quickly.

The border between Oklahoma and Texas was set in 1921: the southern bank of the Red River.  Trouble is, the river tends to move.  In 1996, things were sufficiently out of hand that the two states set up a joint commission to settle the boundary once and for all; it was 2000 before everything was graven in stone.

» Sat   9 Feb 2008   12:09

Kevin McGehee said:

The thing about shifting rivers was, I thought, settled when it was decided the states bordering the Mississippi River still had the same boundaries despite the river’s having moved—thus states all along it have little enclaves on the “wrong” side of the river.

In a way that precedent would argue that the boundary Georgia has lived with for 190 years wouldn’t be changed.

» Sat   9 Feb 2008   13:21


You must be registered and logged in to comment.


<< Previous Entry
Marketing
  Next Entry >>
A Ray of Good News

RECENT POSTS

And Now, a Request

Find Fault

E-Day Data Point

Your Instructions for November 4

The News Moratorium Begins Now

He Probably Already Voted

Time Warped


 

News & Opinion

Drudge Report
Newnan (Ga.) Times-Herald
Fairbanks News-Miner
Sacramento Bee
American Spectator



Archive Search


Advanced Search

 
Archive Browse

LOCAL LINKS
 The McGehee Zone
 cats. iz. perverse.
 The Chris McGehee Pages
 McGehee's Photo Gallery
 The McGehee Clan
 Our Latitude Adjustment
 Play Rough, Fight Dirty

OTHER LINKS
Wikipedia
Ask.com Web Search

ARRL
BGMRC
Clan Gregor Society
Loyal Order of Moose
National Rifle Association

Mozilla Firefox
Mozilla Thunderbird

McGeheeZone Blog Network
on Facebook

 

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More
Support the
Mike Stokely
Foundation
Moo
 
© 2008 Kevin McGehee
Hosted by Verve

ExpressionEngine 1.6.6


Outsourced Commentary

Absinthe and Cookies
Ace of Spades
American Dinosaur
The American Mind
American Power
American Princess
The Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler
Anywhere But Here
Armed and Dangerous
 
Baldilocks
Big Stick Libertarian
Bill Dennis
Bill Hobbs
Bill Peschel
BitsBlog
Blame Bush
Bloody Scott
Blue Crab Boulevard
Brian J. Noggle
 
Cadillac Tight
Capitalist Lion
Cap'n Bob & the Damsel
CaughtintheXfire
Charles Austin
Chiefly Musing
Chizumatic
ClaudePate.com
The Cluttered Eclectic Mind
CollegePundit
Colonel McCormick's Spin
The Command Post
Common Sense and Wonder
Confederate Yankee
Conservative Reader
Cox & Forkum
Craig's Corner
Cranky-D
The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns
 
D.C. Thornton
Da Goddess
Daily Pundit
damnum absque injuria
Darleen's Place
Dave Munger
Dave Worley
The Dax Files
Dawn Patrol
Dean's World
Dispatches from Blogblivion
Dizzy Girl
Dr. Weevil
Dread Pundit Bluto
Dreaded Purple Master
Drink This...
Drumwaster's Rants
Dustbury
 
The Ebb & Flow Institute
Eject! Eject! Eject!
Electric Venom
Eternity Road
Explorations
 
The Fat Guy
Fausta’s Blog
FreedomSight
FullosseousFlap’s Dental Blog
 
Grandma's House
Guide to Midwestern Culture
Gut Rumbles
 
Half a Pica Distance
Hog on Ice
HolyCoast.com
Horologium
 
INCITE
Indigo Insights
Inoperable Terran
Inside Charm City
Instapundit
The Interocitor
The Irish Lass
 
Jawa Report
JenLars
Jim Treacher
Juan Gato
JunkYardBlog
Just Some Poor Schmuck
 
Kim du Toit
 
La Shawn Barber's Corner
LeatherPenguin
Leslie's Omnibus
Lilac Rose
The Line Is Here
Lintefiniel Musing
Little Miss Attila
LIVE! From BFE
Llama Butchers
Local Malcontent
 
Macker's World
Mean Ol' Meany
Michelle Malkin
Mike Antonucci
The Mind of Mog
Mister Snitch!
Moxie
mtpolitics
Musing Minds
MVRWC
 
Neal Sheeran
No Watermelons Allowed
The Nose on Your Face
Not Exactly Rocket Science
Nuke 'm Hill
 
Ogre's Politics and Views
Old Grouch
On the Other Foot
One Fine Jay
One Good Turn
The Original Musings
The Other McCain
 
Patterico's Pontifications
The Palit Journals
Pillage Idiot
PoliPundit
The Poor Farm
Porphyrogenitus
Possumblog
Power Line
PrestoPundit
Primordial Slack
Protein Wisdom
Prudence Ponder
Psssst! Over Here!
Pull On Superman's Cape
PW Pub
 
The Quilting Corner
 
Rachel Lucas
Random Commands
Rantburg
Read My Lips
ResurrectionSong
Riehl World View
Right As Usual
The Right Place
Right Wing Sparkle
Roughstock Journal
Russ. Just Russ.
 
samaBlog
Scared Monkeys
Scribal Terror
Serr8d's Cutting Edge
Shadowscope
Shark Blog
Sharp as a Marble
Sister Toldjah
Six Meat Buffet
Small Dead Animals
Small Pieces
The Smallest Minority
Snugg Harbor
Stop the ACLU
Straight White Guy
The Sundries Shack
 
Technically Speaking
This Blog Is Full of Crap
Toys in the Attic
Transterrestrial Musings
Triticale
Twisted Spinster
 
Unidentified Avenger
 
Velociworld
The View From Out Here
VodkaPundit
Volokh Conspiracy
A Voyage to Arcturus
 
Wave Maker
WickedPinto
The Window Manager
Winds of Change
Wizbang
 
Zero Base Thinking